Relationship of Time and Motion Study to Work Study

Work Study is the overarching discipline focused on improving productivity by systematically analyzing work methods. It consists of two core, interdependent techniques: Method Study (primarily using Motion Study) and Work Measurement (primarily using Time Study). Think of Work Study as the parent field. Method Study uses Motion Study to find the most efficient way to do a job by eliminating wasteful motions. Once this best method is established, Time Study is applied to determine the standard time a qualified worker should take to perform that now-optimized task. They are sequential and complementary tools for systematic improvement.

  • Work Study as the Umbrella Discipline

Work Study is the broad, systematic examination of human work to improve efficiency and productivity. It is formally divided into two main components: Method Study and Work Measurement. Method Study is concerned with the “how” of a job—the procedures and motions used. Work Measurement is concerned with the “how long”—the time required. Time Study and Motion Study are not separate from Work Study; they are the principal analytical tools within this framework. Therefore, Work Study provides the structured methodology, while Time and Motion Studies are the specific techniques used to execute its two fundamental purposes.

  • Motion Study as a Tool of Method Study

Motion Study is a foundational technique used within the Method Study component of Work Study. Its specific role is to analyze and refine the body movements of a worker. By breaking down tasks into fundamental elements (Therbligs), it identifies and eliminates unnecessary, inefficient, or fatiguing motions. The goal of Motion Study is to establish the “one best way” to perform a task in terms of movement sequence, tool placement, and workplace layout. It focuses purely on method optimization, ensuring the work is done with the least possible effort and time before any timing occurs.

  • Time Study as a Tool of Work Measurement

Time Study is the core technique used within the Work Measurement component of Work Study. Its role is to determine the standard time a qualified worker should take to complete a specified task while working at a normal pace. Crucially, Time Study is applied after the method has been optimized by Method Study (and its tool, Motion Study). It quantifies the work content of the established “best method.” This measured standard time is then used for scheduling, costing, and performance evaluation, providing the critical quantitative data that completes the Work Study cycle.

  • The Sequential and Complementary Relationship

The relationship is sequential and symbiotic. Motion Study (for method) must precede Time Study (for measurement). It is illogical and inefficient to time an unrefined method, as this would simply standardize existing inefficiencies. First, Motion Study develops the most effective procedure. Second, Time Study determines a fair time standard for that specific procedure. They are complementary: Motion Study improves efficiency by refining how the work is done, and Time Study establishes a benchmark for how long it should take. Together, under the umbrella of Work Study, they ensure that work is both well-designed and accurately measured.

  • The Integration for a Complete Productivity Solution

The true power of these studies lies in their integration. Work Study provides the problem-solving framework. Within it, Motion Study acts as the qualitative analyst, focusing on human factors, ergonomics, and the logic of motion to design a superior method. Time Study then acts as the quantitative analyst, attaching a numerical value to that method. This integration ensures that productivity improvements are holistic; they are not just faster (Time Study’s contribution) but also smarter, safer, and less fatiguing (Motion Study’s contribution). One without the other provides an incomplete solution.

  • Impact on Standardization and Training

The combined use of Motion and Time Study within the Work Study framework is the bedrock of operational standardization. Motion Study defines the precise, step-by-step method, while Time Study defines the expected pace. This creates a clear, unified standard for how work should be performed across the organization. This standard method and time then become the basis for all operator training programs. New employees are taught the one best way from the start, leading to faster onboarding, consistent output quality, and uniform performance expectations, which are critical for stable operations.

  • Role in Continuous Improvement (Kaizen)

Work Study, through its twin tools, institutionalizes continuous improvement. Motion Study is not a one-time event; it encourages ongoing scrutiny of methods to find even better ways. Similarly, Time Studies can be re-conducted to validate standards after any method change. This creates a cycle: a new method is developed (Motion Study), a new standard time is set (Time Study), performance is measured against it, and the search for further improvements begins again. This data-driven cycle is the essence of methodologies like Kaizen, making Work Study a foundational practice for lean manufacturing.

  • Economic Justification and Investment Analysis

The relationship provides a robust model for economic justification of changes. Motion Study identifies a potential method improvement, such as a new tool or layout. Time Study then quantifies the time (and therefore cost) savings of implementing that change. By comparing the projected labor savings from the new time standard against the cost of the investment, management can make a data-driven decision. This synergy allows Work Study to function not just as an efficiency tool, but as a strategic financial tool for prioritizing improvement projects based on their return on investment.

  • Enhancing Fairness and Industrial Relations

When implemented transparently, this relationship fosters fairness and trust. Motion Study demonstrates management’s commitment to reducing unnecessary effort and fatigue, showing concern for worker well-being. The subsequent Time Study, based on this fair method, produces a standard time that is perceived as legitimate and achievable. This combats the perception that time standards are arbitrarily designed to speed up work unreasonably. By visibly linking the time standard to a well-designed method, Work Study helps build cooperative industrial relations, as employees are more likely to accept standards derived from a scientific and equitable process.

Leave a Reply

error: Content is protected !!