Contingent contracts are an important aspect of contract law, particularly in India, where they are governed by the Indian Contract Act, 1872. These contracts hinge on the occurrence or non-occurrence of a specific event, making their execution conditional.
Nature of Contingent Contracts:
According to Section 31 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a contingent contract is defined as “a contract to do or not to do something, if some event, collateral to such contract, does or does not happen.” Essentially, the performance of a contingent contract depends on a future event that is uncertain. If the event occurs, the contract becomes enforceable; if it does not, the contract is void.
Key Elements of Contingent Contracts:
-
Future Event: The contract’s enforcement is dependent on a future event that is uncertain.
- Collateral Event: The event must be collateral to the contract, meaning it is not part of the contract’s consideration.
- Uncertainty: The future event must be uncertain, adding a level of risk to the agreement.
Types of Contingent Contracts:
- Contracts Dependent on the Happening of an Event
- Contracts Dependent on the Non-Happening of an Event
- Contracts Dependent on the Conduct of a Third Party
- Contracts Dependent on an Uncertain Event within a Fixed Time
- Contracts Dependent on the Non-Happening of an Event within a Fixed Time
-
Contracts Dependent on the Happening of an Event
These contracts become enforceable when a specific event occurs.
Example: A agrees to pay B ₹50,000 if B’s house, which is currently on sale, is sold.
-
Contracts Dependent on the Non-Happening of an Event
These contracts become enforceable when a specific event does not occur.
Example: A agrees to sell goods to B if a shipment from C does not arrive by a certain date.
-
Contracts Dependent on the Conduct of a Third Party
These contracts depend on the actions of a third party, not directly involved in the contract.
Example: A agrees to buy B’s car if C, a car mechanic, certifies it to be in good condition.
-
Contracts Dependent on an Uncertain Event within a Fixed Time
These contracts are conditional on the occurrence of an uncertain event within a specified period.
Example: A agrees to build a house for B if B obtains a loan from the bank within three months.
-
Contracts Dependent on the Non-Happening of an Event within a Fixed Time
These contracts are conditional on an uncertain event not occurring within a specified period.
Example: A agrees to marry B if C, B’s previous suitor, does not return from abroad within a year.
Enforceability of Contingent Contracts:
Sections 32 to 36 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, detail the enforceability of contingent contracts.
- Section 32: Enforceability on the Happening of an Event
Contracts contingent on the occurrence of an event cannot be enforced until the event has occurred. If the event becomes impossible, the contract is void.
Example: A agrees to sell B his house if he inherits it from his uncle. If the uncle disinherits A, the contract becomes void.
- Section 33: Enforceability on the Non-Happening of an Event
Contracts contingent on the non-happening of an event can be enforced when it is certain that the event will not happen.
Example: A agrees to pay B if a particular ship does not return. If the ship sinks, making its return impossible, the contract becomes enforceable.
- Section 34: Future Conduct of a Living Person
If a contract is contingent on how a person will act at an unspecified future time, it can only be enforced when the person acts in the manner specified or when such action becomes impossible.
Example: A agrees to sell property to B if C refuses to buy it. The contract becomes enforceable only when C refuses.
- Section 35: Event Happening within a Fixed Time
If a contract is contingent on an event happening within a fixed time, it becomes void if the event does not occur within that time or if it becomes certain that the event will not occur.
Example: A agrees to sell goods to B if B’s ship arrives within a month. If the ship does not arrive within a month, the contract is void.
- Section 36: Impossibility of Event
Contingent contracts based on an impossible event are void, irrespective of whether the parties were aware of the impossibility.
Example: A agrees to pay B ₹10,000 if B can make a dead man alive. This contract is void as the event is impossible.
Examples and Case Laws:
- Example 1: Insurance Contracts
Most insurance contracts are contingent contracts. For instance, a life insurance policy is contingent on the death of the insured person. The insurer is liable to pay the sum assured only upon the occurrence of the insured event, i.e., death.
- Example 2: Contracts Dependent on Market Prices
A contract to buy goods if the market price drops to a certain level is contingent on the market price.
Example: A agrees to buy wheat from B if the market price falls below ₹20 per kg.
Case Law: Satyabrata Ghose v. Mugneeram Bangur & Co. (1954)
In this landmark case, the Supreme Court of India held that a contract contingent on the non-happening of an event is void if the event occurs, and the performance becomes impossible.
One thought on “Contingent contract, Nature, Elements, Types”