Incoming Partner, a person newly admitted to an existing firm. Under Section 31(1), subject to any contract between the partners, no person can be introduced as a partner without the consent of all existing partners. The entrant must be competent to contract under Section 11 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. A minor can only be admitted to the benefits of partnership under Section 30. Under Section 31(2), an incoming partner is not liable for acts of the firm done before he became a partner. His liability for later acts is joint and several under Section 25. English law under the Partnership Act 1890 follows the same principle.
Modes of Admission of Incoming Partner:
1. Admission by Agreement with Consent of All Existing Partners
Under Section 31(1) of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, subject to any contract between the partners, a person may be introduced as a partner only with the consent of all existing partners. The usual mode is therefore an express agreement, oral or written, in which existing partners and the entrant settle the profit-sharing ratio, capital contribution, and duties. A deed of admission or a supplementary partnership deed is advisable for proof. The entrant must be competent to contract under Section 11 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. English law under the Partnership Act 1890 likewise requires unanimous consent.
2. Admission under a Clause in the Partnership Deed
Section 31(1) allows the partners to agree otherwise, so the original partnership deed may itself provide a method of admission. It may permit a majority to admit new partners, authorise a named partner to nominate a successor or a family member, or allow admission on the death or retirement of a partner. Such a clause is binding, and the new partner’s admission follows the deed without fresh unanimous consent. Family businesses often use this clause to bring in the next generation. International partnership agreements likewise state admission rules in advance, as in English law, where the agreement governs.
3. Admission of a Minor to the Benefits of Partnership
Under Section 30, a minor cannot be a full partner because he is not competent to contract under Section 11, but with the consent of all partners he may be admitted to the benefits of the partnership. He shares in the profits and property, but is not personally liable for the firm’s debts, only his share being at risk. Within six months of attaining majority, he must elect to become a partner or not, and give public notice of the choice. If he does not, he becomes a partner with full liability. English law gives a minor similar protection.
4. Admission by Purchase or Assignment of a Partner’s Interest
A person may enter the firm by acquiring a partner’s interest, but under Section 29, an assignee of a partner’s share does not become a partner and has no right to interfere in management, inspect books, or demand accounts. He is entitled only to the assignor’s share of profits and, on dissolution, to the share of assets. He becomes a partner only if the other partners consent under Section 31(1) and accept him as one. English law applies the same rule, so the buyer of a share is not automatically a partner.
5. Admission by Conduct, Holding Out or Implied Consent
A person may be treated as a partner, even without a formal agreement, by the conduct of the existing partners. Under Section 5, partnership arises from contract, which may be implied from the course of dealing, sharing of profits, and participation in business. Under Section 28, one who represents himself, or knowingly allows himself to be represented, as a partner is liable as a partner to third parties who give credit on that faith, through holding out (estoppel). Admission by implication is hard to prove, so a written deed is preferable. English and international law recognise the same doctrine.
6. Consequences and Formalities after Admission
On admission, the firm is reconstituted, and the new partner’s rights are those given by Section 12 to 17 and the deed. Under Section 31(2), he is not liable for acts done before admission, though his liability for later acts is joint and several under Section 25. The firm should notify the Registrar of Firms of the change under Section 63, and publish public notice if it wishes to avoid doubt. An unregistered firm’s rights are limited by Section 69. English law requires disclosure of changes to third parties in similar form.
Rights of Incoming Partner:
1. Right to Share in the Profits
An incoming partner is entitled to share in the firm’s profits from the date of admission, in the ratio agreed in the deed of admission. Under Section 13(b) of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, subject to contract, partners are entitled to share equally in profits and must bear losses equally. He has no claim to profits earned before admission, as Section 31(2) frees him from earlier liabilities and the firm’s earlier results belong to the old partners. The partners may agree to goodwill or premium adjustments on entry. English law under the Partnership Act 1890 gives the same right.
2. Right to Take Part in the Conduct of the Business
Under Section 12(a), subject to contract, every partner has the right to take part in the conduct of the business. The incoming partner may therefore join in management, make decisions, and bind the firm by acts done in the usual course of business under Sections 18 and 19. Under Section 12(c), every partner has the right to express his opinion before any matter is decided by a majority, and Section 12(d) requires unanimous consent for a change in the nature of the business. Partners may restrict this right in the deed, as in English law, where the agreement governs.
3. Right to Access Books and Inspect Accounts
Under Section 12(d), every partner has the right of access to, and the right to inspect and copy, any of the books of the firm. The incoming partner can examine accounts, records of receipts and payments, and the opening balance sheet to verify the firm’s position at entry. Under Section 9, partners must render true accounts and full information on all things affecting the firm. This right is essential because he is not liable for pre-admission debts but will share future results. English law and international partnership practice give partners the same right of inspection.
4. Right to Be Indemnified and to Receive Interest
Under Section 13(c), where a partner makes a payment or advance beyond the amount of capital he has agreed to subscribe, he is entitled to interest at 6 per cent per annum, subject to contract. Under Section 13(e), the firm must indemnify him in respect of payments made and liabilities incurred by him in the ordinary and proper conduct of the business, or in an emergency to protect the firm from loss. Under Section 13(a), a partner is not entitled to remuneration for taking part in the business unless the contract provides. English law is similar.
5. Right Not to Be Liable for Earlier Acts of the Firm
Under Section 31(2), an incoming partner is not liable for any act of the firm done before he became a partner. Creditors of the old firm cannot proceed against his personal assets for earlier debts. He may agree to assume them, and the creditors may then enforce the agreement, but there is no liability without such an agreement. His liability for later acts is joint and several under Section 25. A new partner joining a firm with an outstanding bank loan is therefore protected. English law applies the same principle.
6. Right to Continue and Right against Expulsion or Change without Consent
Under Section 12(c), subject to contract, no change in the nature of the business may be made without the consent of all partners, and under Section 17, the entrant shares in the firm’s property and goodwill on the terms of the deed. Under Section 33, a partner cannot be expelled except in good faith and under a power conferred by contract. Under Section 7, a firm may be a partnership at will, so he continues until he gives notice of dissolution or retires under Section 32. Similar protections exist in English law.
Liabilities of Incoming Partner:
1. No Liability for Acts Before Admission
Under Section 31(2) of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, an incoming partner is not liable for any act of the firm done before he became a partner. Creditors of the old firm cannot proceed against his personal assets for earlier debts or contracts. For example, a person joining a firm with an outstanding bank loan is not personally liable for it by reason of admission alone. He may, however, voluntarily assume such liability by agreement, and creditors may then enforce it. English law under the Partnership Act 1890 follows the same principle.
2. Joint and Several Liability for Acts After Admission
From the date of admission, the incoming partner is liable, jointly with all other partners and also severally, for all acts of the firm under Section 25. A creditor may recover the entire debt from his personal property if the firm’s assets and other partners’ payments fall short. His liability is unlimited. A partner who joins on 1 April is liable for goods purchased by the firm on 1 May, to the full extent of his private assets. He may then claim contribution from the other partners. English and international partnership law impose similar liability.
3. Liability for Acts of Other Partners
Under Sections 18 and 19, every partner is the agent of the firm, and acts done in the usual course of business bind the firm and all partners, including the incoming partner. If a co-partner signs a supply contract within his implied authority, the new partner is bound even if he did not know of it. Under Section 22, the act must be done in the firm name or in a manner showing intention to bind the firm. Acts outside this authority do not bind him unless he ratifies them. English law applies the same mutual agency principle.
4. Liability for Wrongful Acts and Misapplication of Funds
Under Section 26, the firm, and therefore every partner including the incoming partner, is liable for a wrongful act or omission of a partner done in the ordinary course of business or with the authority of the other partners. Under Section 27, the firm is also liable where a partner misapplies money or property received from a third party in the course of the firm’s business. This applies only to wrongs committed after admission. For example, if a partner defrauds a client after the new partner joins, he shares liability to the client. English law follows vicarious liability for partners’ torts.
5. Liability to Co-Partners: Losses, Duties and Good Faith
Under Section 13(b), subject to contract, the incoming partner must bear losses equally with other partners, or as per the agreed ratio. Under Section 9, he must carry on the business for the greatest common advantage, be just and faithful, and render true accounts. Under Section 16, he must account for any secret profit from firm transactions or from use of firm property or business connection, and under Section 12(b), he must attend diligently to his duties. He is also liable to indemnify the firm under Section 10 for loss caused by his wilful neglect. English law imposes similar fiduciary duties.
6. Liability by Agreement and by Holding Out
An incoming partner may become liable for earlier debts by a fresh agreement with creditors, such as a novation under Section 62 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, where the creditor accepts him as a debtor for the old firm’s liability. Under Section 28 of the Partnership Act, he is also liable by holding out if he represents himself, or allows himself to be represented, as a partner before formal admission, to anyone who gives credit on that faith. A person whose name appears on the firm’s letterhead before admission is an example. English and international law recognise the same estoppel rule.
7. Liability of a Minor Admitted and Liability on Reconstitution
If the incoming person is a minor admitted to the benefits of partnership under Section 30, he is not personally liable for the firm’s acts, and only his share in the property and profits is at risk. If he fails to elect within six months of attaining majority, he becomes a partner under Section 30(5), liable for all firm acts since admission. On reconstitution, the Registrar of Firms should be notified under Section 63, and liability for later acts continues until public notice of retirement is given under Section 72. English law gives a minor similar protection.
Outgoing Partners Definition under Indian Partnership Act, 1932
The Act does not define “outgoing partner” in a single section, but the term describes a person who ceases to be a partner while the firm continues, whether by retirement, expulsion, death, insolvency, or assignment of his interest. Section 32 deals with retirement: a partner may retire with the consent of all other partners, in accordance with an express agreement, or, in a partnership at will, by giving written notice of his intention to retire. Section 33 governs expulsion and Sections 34 to 35 deal with insolvency and death. Under Section 32(2), he remains liable for acts done before retirement until discharged, and under Section 32(3), for later acts until public notice is given under Section 72. English law under the Partnership Act 1890 is similar.
Modes of Outgoing Partner:
1. Retirement with Consent of All Partners
Under Section 32(1)(a) of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, a partner may retire with the consent of all the other partners. This is the commonest mode, and the terms of exit, such as payment for his share, goodwill, and release from future liability, are settled by agreement. A written deed of retirement is advisable for proof. The retiring partner remains liable for earlier acts of the firm until discharged under Section 32(2), and for later acts until public notice is given under Section 72. English law under the Partnership Act 1890 likewise allows exit by agreement of the partners.
2. Retirement in Accordance with an Express Agreement
Under Section 32(1)(b), a partner may retire in accordance with an express agreement among the partners, usually found in the partnership deed. The deed may fix a notice period, permit retirement at a stated age, or allow exit on specified events, without fresh consent from every partner. The clause binds all partners, so a retirement made as per its terms is valid. Family firms and professional firms commonly include such provisions to ensure orderly succession. International partnership agreements likewise set exit procedures in advance, and in English law the agreement governs the manner of retirement.
3. Retirement by Notice in a Partnership at Will
Under Section 32(1)(c), where the partnership is at will, a partner may retire by giving written notice to all the other partners of his intention to retire. A partnership at will is one with no fixed term and no provision for determination, as per Section 7. The retirement takes effect from the date stated in the notice, or on its receipt if none is stated. The firm continues among the remaining partners, and the outgoing partner should publish public notice under Section 72. English law gives a similar right to leave a partnership at will on notice.
4. Expulsion
Under Section 33(1), a partner may not be expelled from the firm by a majority of the partners, except in the exercise in good faith of a power conferred by contract between the partners. Expulsion must therefore rest on an express clause in the deed, follow the stated procedure, and be for the benefit of the firm, not for personal motive. Under Section 33(2), an expelled partner has the same rights and liabilities as a retiring partner, and courts may set aside a mala fide expulsion. English law applies the same rule that expulsion needs a contractual power exercised in good faith.
5. Insolvency of a Partner
Under Section 34(1), where a partner is adjudicated an insolvent, he ceases to be a partner on the date of the order, whether or not the firm is thereby dissolved. This happens by operation of law, without any act of the partners. Under Section 34(2), his estate is not liable for acts of the firm done after the date of the order, and the firm is not liable for his acts after that date. Under Section 42(d), the firm is dissolved on a partner’s insolvency unless there is a contract to the contrary. English law is similar.
6. Death of a Partner
Under Section 35, where a firm is constituted for no fixed term, the death of a partner ends his membership. Where the deed so provides, the firm continues among the surviving partners. In this case, the estate of the deceased partner is not liable for acts of the firm done after his death, as Section 35 states. Under Section 42(c), the death of a partner dissolves the firm, subject to a contract to the contrary. The legal heirs are entitled to the deceased partner’s share under Sections 37 and 53, and the firm may continue after paying them. English law is similar.
7. Other Modes: Assignment of Interest and Incapacity
A partner may cease to take part in the firm by assigning his interest, but under Section 29, the assignee does not become a partner. He is entitled only to the assignor’s share of profits and, on dissolution, to his share of assets. A partner may also be effectively excluded by being declared of unsound mind, which affects his capacity to contract under Section 11 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, and may justify dissolution by the court under Section 44(a). English law applies similar rules on assignment and mental incapacity.
Rights of Outgoing Partner:
1. Right to Share in Profits or Interest on His Share
Under Section 37 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, where a firm continues after a partner has ceased to be a partner, and no final settlement of accounts has been made, the outgoing partner (or his estate) is entitled, at his option, to such share of the profits earned since he ceased to be a partner as is attributable to the use of his share of the property, or to interest at 6 per cent per annum on the amount of his share. The remaining partners may exclude this by contract, such as an option to purchase his interest. English law under the Partnership Act 1890 gives a similar choice.
2. Right to Receive the Value of His Share and Goodwill
An outgoing partner is entitled to be paid the value of his share in the firm’s assets, including his capital, undrawn profits, and a proportionate part of goodwill, as settled by agreement or by an account taken on the date of exit. Under Section 17, subject to contract, the property of the firm includes goodwill, so the outgoing partner has an interest in it. Under Section 55, goodwill is sold on dissolution for the benefit of all partners. Firms often value goodwill by a formula in the deed or by a valuer, as in English and international practice.
3. Right to Carry on a Competing Business and Advertise
Under Section 36(1), an outgoing partner may carry on a business competing with that of the firm and advertise it, but he may not use the firm name, represent himself as carrying on the firm’s business, or solicit the firm’s old customers, unless there is a contract to the contrary. Under Section 36(2), a partner may agree with his partners that on ceasing to be a partner he will not carry on a similar business within a specified period or local limits, and such an agreement is valid if the restrictions are reasonable. This is an exception to Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. English law applies the restraint of trade doctrine.
4. Right to Be Released from Liability for Future Acts
Under Section 32(3), a retiring partner continues to be liable to third parties for acts of the firm done after retirement until public notice of the retirement is given under Section 72, but he is not liable to a person who deals with the firm without knowing that he was a partner. His right is therefore to protect himself by giving notice to the Registrar of Firms and publishing it in the Official Gazette and a local newspaper. Under Section 34 and Section 35, the estate of an insolvent or deceased partner is not liable for acts after the event. English law is similar.
5. Right to Be Discharged from Past Liabilities and to Indemnity
Under Section 32(2), a retiring partner remains liable for acts done before retirement until discharged by agreement made between him, the new firm and the creditors, and Section 32(3) allows this to be implied from the course of dealing between the creditor and the reconstituted firm. He may therefore seek a novation or an express indemnity from the continuing partners against old debts, which is commonly included in the retirement deed. Under Section 13(e), the firm must indemnify a partner for liabilities incurred in the proper conduct of business. English law recognises the same practice.
6. Right to Accounts, Information and Payment of His Dues
Under Section 37 and Section 48, an outgoing partner is entitled to a settlement of accounts and payment of the amount due to him, and he may inspect the books for the period he was a partner under Section 12(d). Where the firm is dissolved or the remaining partners fail to pay, he may sue for an account and for his share. Under Section 48, losses are paid first out of profits, then capital, then by partners in their profit-sharing ratio, and the balance is paid to each partner. The right extends to his legal representatives on death, as in English law.
Liabilities of Outgoing Partner:
1. Liability for Acts Done Before Retirement
Under Section 32(2) of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, a retiring partner and the other partners continue to be liable to third parties for all acts of the firm done before his retirement. The liability ends only when he is discharged by an agreement made between himself, the new firm, and the creditors. A creditor of the old firm can therefore still sue him personally for a bank loan taken before he left. He may seek an indemnity from the continuing partners. English law under the Partnership Act 1890 follows the same principle.
2. Discharge by Agreement or Course of Dealing
Under Section 32(3), the discharge of a retiring partner from past liabilities may be implied from the course of dealing between the creditor and the reconstituted firm. For example, where the creditor, knowing of the retirement, continues to deal with the new firm and accepts payments from it, the old partner may be treated as discharged. This amounts to a form of novation under Section 62 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Silence alone is usually not enough, so a written release is advisable. English law applies a similar rule of discharge by novation.
3. Liability for Acts After Retirement Until Public Notice
Under Section 32(3), a retired partner continues to be liable to third parties for the firm’s acts done after retirement until public notice of the retirement is given under Section 72. This rests on the principle of holding out, since outsiders may rely on his continued membership. Notice is given to the Registrar of Firms and published in the Official Gazette and a local vernacular newspaper. Once notice is given, liability for later acts ends. English law imposes similar liability until notice is given to the world.
4. No Liability to Persons Unaware of Partnership
Under Section 32(3), the retired partner is not liable for acts after retirement to a person who deals with the firm without knowing that he was a partner. This protects a partner against claims by customers who never knew of his connection with the firm, such as a person dealing only with the firm’s active partners. The burden of showing lack of knowledge lies on the claimant’s dealings. Where there was knowledge, public notice is required to end liability, as in English law, where persons who never knew of the partnership cannot hold the partner liable.
5. Liability of Expelled, Insolvent and Deceased Partners
Under Section 33(2), an expelled partner has the same rights and liabilities as a retiring partner. Under Section 34(2), the estate of a partner adjudged insolvent is not liable for acts of the firm after the date of the order, and the firm is not liable for his acts after that date. Under Section 35, the estate of a deceased partner is not liable for acts after his death, though it remains liable for earlier acts until discharged. Public notice is not required in these two cases, as in English law.
6. Liability to the Firm and Co-Partners
An outgoing partner remains answerable to the firm for breaches committed while he was a partner, such as secret profits under Section 16, wilful neglect causing loss under Section 10, or fraud against the firm. He must also account for his share of losses incurred before exit under Section 13(b). After exit, Section 36(1) bars him from using the firm name or representing himself as carrying on the firm’s business, and any valid restraint agreed under Section 36(2) binds him within reasonable limits. English law applies similar duties and restraints.
7. Liability on Continuing Use of Firm Name and Payment to Outgoing Partner’s Share
Under Section 36(1), an outgoing partner may not use the firm name. Where he or his name is allowed to continue in the firm name, he may be liable under Section 28 by holding out to those who give credit. Under Section 37, where the firm continues after he leaves and accounts are not settled, he or his estate may claim a share of profits or 6 per cent interest, and the continuing partners bear the burden of paying him. The risk of liability for his share remains with the firm. English law gives similar protection.