Marginal costing is a technique of costing in which only variable costs are charged to products or services, while fixed costs are treated as period costs and written off against the contribution of the period in which they are incurred. It distinguishes between fixed and variable costs, unlike absorption costing which apportions both to units produced. The core concept is contribution, calculated as sales minus variable cost, which helps management understand the incremental profitability of each unit. This approach is widely used for short term decision making such as pricing, make or buy choices, and product mix decisions. In Bihar, small agro based units processing litchi and makhana often use similar variable cost thinking informally when deciding seasonal production levels and pricing during peak harvest months.
Characteristics of Marginal Costing:
1. Separation of Fixed and Variable Costs
Marginal costing clearly classifies costs into fixed costs and variable costs. Variable costs change with the level of production, while fixed costs remain constant within a certain range of activity. This separation helps management understand cost behavior, calculate contribution, and make effective business decisions regarding pricing, production, and profitability.
2. Variable Costs Charged to Products
Under marginal costing, only variable production costs such as direct materials, direct labour, and variable overheads are charged to the cost of products. Fixed manufacturing overheads are treated as period costs and are written off against the profit of the accounting period. This provides a clear view of the variable cost of production.
3. Fixed Costs Treated as Period Costs
Fixed costs are not included in product cost under marginal costing. Instead, they are charged directly to the Profit and Loss Account for the period in which they are incurred. Since fixed costs do not change with production volume, they are considered expenses of the accounting period rather than production costs.
4. Focus on Contribution
Marginal costing emphasizes contribution, which is the difference between sales and variable costs. Contribution is used first to recover fixed costs, and the remaining amount represents profit. This concept helps management evaluate product profitability, determine the break even point, and make short term business decisions.
5. Useful for Decision Making
Marginal costing provides relevant cost information for managerial decisions such as pricing, product selection, make or buy decisions, accepting special orders, and determining the most profitable product mix. It focuses on costs that change with business decisions, making it an effective tool for management.
6. Simplifies Cost Control
By concentrating on variable costs and treating fixed costs separately, marginal costing makes cost analysis and control easier. Managers can identify changes in variable costs, monitor efficiency, reduce unnecessary expenses, and improve profitability through better operational control and planning.
7. Suitable for Short Term Planning
Marginal costing is mainly used for short term planning and operational decisions. It helps management estimate the impact of changes in production, sales volume, and pricing on profit. Since fixed costs remain constant in the short run, the method provides reliable information for quick and effective decision making.
Absorption Costing
Absorption costing, also called full costing, is a method where both fixed and variable manufacturing costs are absorbed into the cost of a product. Unlike marginal costing, it does not distinguish between fixed and variable costs for reporting purposes, treating both as product costs that form part of inventory valuation until the goods are sold. This approach follows the matching principle and is required under most accounting standards including Ind AS for external financial reporting. Fixed overheads are apportioned to units using a predetermined absorption rate, often based on labour hours or machine hours. In Bihar, medium scale manufacturing units, such as those producing packaged makhana or processed litchi products, typically rely on absorption costing when preparing statutory financial statements for tax authorities and lenders.
Characteristics of Absorption Costing:
1. Includes Both Fixed and Variable Costs
Absorption costing includes both variable and fixed manufacturing costs in the cost of a product. Direct materials, direct labour, variable factory overheads, and fixed factory overheads are absorbed into the product cost. This provides the total manufacturing cost of each unit produced.
2. Fixed Manufacturing Overheads are Absorbed
A key characteristic of absorption costing is that fixed manufacturing overheads are allocated to each unit of production. These costs are treated as product costs rather than period costs. As a result, every unit produced carries a share of fixed factory expenses, ensuring complete cost allocation.
3. Complete Product Costing
Absorption costing determines the total cost of production by including all manufacturing expenses. This gives a comprehensive view of product cost, making it useful for pricing decisions, inventory valuation, and financial reporting. It ensures that every manufacturing cost is included in the cost of the product.
4. Inventory Includes Fixed Overheads
Under absorption costing, closing inventory is valued by including both variable and fixed manufacturing costs. Therefore, a portion of fixed factory overhead remains included in unsold inventory until the goods are sold. This affects the valuation of inventory and the reported profit.
5. Suitable for Financial Reporting
Absorption costing is widely accepted for preparing financial statements because it follows accounting principles that require all manufacturing costs to be included in product cost. It is commonly used for external financial reporting, taxation, and inventory valuation.
6. Profit Depends on Production and Sales
Under absorption costing, profit is influenced by both the number of units produced and the number of units sold. If production exceeds sales, some fixed overhead is carried forward in closing inventory, which may increase reported profit. Therefore, profit can vary with changes in inventory levels.
7. Useful for Long Term Cost Analysis
Absorption costing provides complete cost information by including all manufacturing expenses. This makes it suitable for long term planning, pricing decisions, budgeting, and cost analysis. It helps management recover both fixed and variable manufacturing costs through product pricing, ensuring sustainable business operations.
Key Differences between Marginal Costing and Absorption Costing
| Basis | Marginal Costing | Absorption Costing |
|---|---|---|
| Cost Inclusion | Variable costs only | Fixed and variable costs |
| Fixed Overheads | Period cost | Product cost |
| Product Cost | Variable cost only | Total manufacturing cost |
| Inventory Valuation | Excludes fixed overhead | Includes fixed overhead |
| Profit Basis | Based on sales | Based on production and sales |
| Closing Stock | Lower value | Higher value |
| Cost Classification | Fixed and variable | Functional classification |
| Contribution | Calculated | Not emphasized |
| Break Even Analysis | Possible | Not suitable |
| Decision Making | Highly useful | Less useful |
| Cost Control | Better variable cost control | Overall manufacturing cost control |
| Financial Reporting | Not accepted for external reporting | Accepted for external reporting |
| Profit Fluctuation | Less affected by inventory | Affected by inventory changes |
| Application | Short term decisions | Long term reporting |
| Overhead Treatment | Written off in period | Absorbed into products |
3 thoughts on “Key Differences between Marginal Costing and Absorption Costing”